Increasing security by adding the Aqara U200
By adding a matter enabled automatic door lock I was able to not only achieve higher security, but also great convenience for the whole family.
Intro
I’ve been thinking about adding a smart lock to our home for quite some time. As always the first thing that comes to mind is the security aspect.
- What if someone can capture the signal to the door lock and unlock the door later without you knowing?
- What if you are not at home and someone with the technical knowledge will take a shot at your door and (force) brute its way into your home?
- What if a hacker can use a known or unknown vulnerability to enter the house?
These are all valid questions, but from my perspective they just disguise the one rule that was always true for breakins which is
If someone wants to enter your home, they will find a way that is quick, easy and silent.
This kind of defeats the first two questions, because to be able to capture the signal you would need to have special hardware and/or be pretty close to the sender. Which in an environment like ours wouldn’t work.
The second case is also not very likely, since the door in question is covered by a security camera and in a neighborhood like hours, people would ask questions if someone takes a longer time to enter the house from its sidedoor.
Which brings us to question number three and this is actually a valid point. If there is a unknown vulnerability that gets exploited it’s hard to defend. Again, the security camera would likely record the intruder and the person would have to have a bit of luck to find the right window for attacking or have a vulnerability at hand that has been present for quite some time, since I regularily update my devices.
WAP
The “wife approval factor” played a key role in our buying decision. For my wife who regularily forgets to take her keys with her or decides to leave them at home, it’s a game changer to be able to open a door with a device she always carries on herself - her cellphone.
The second positive attribute with the automatic door lock is the fact that our oldest daughter now needs to be able to enter our house without her parents being present, because we both are working and might not be at home, when she’s returning from school. And with the fingerprint sensor that comes with the smart lock, there is no need for remembering a code or having to have a separate device (like an NFC chip) on or with her.
Visuals
Granted you need to get used to the clunky thing that you have to put on/over your door key from the inside of your door, but compared to what was available on the market in the early days of smart locks, you can still with this form factor, because the unique selling point is, you don’t have to drill holes into your door.
If you’re lucky, which I wasn’t, you can even get away with screwing the smart lock onto your doors’ locking cylinder. In our case, we have a cover around the cylinder so I had to use their provided 3M pads to be able to “glue” the device onto the door. But this worked pretty well. Even in my case where I didn’t really get the device 100% level with the lock.
To be able to lock and unlock the door from the outside, Aqara gives you a keypad that you can attach to the outside of your door by either glueing or screwing it on there. You can even ditch the batteries that you might have to replace every once in a while with a hard wired power connection.
Configuration
To be able to configure your smart lock you need to connect your smartphone via Bluetooth and through the Aqara Home app. In the app you can add users and to those users you can add specific unlocking mechanisims like Fingerprints or (temporary) Codes. From within the app you can also directly lock and unlock your door.
The Aqara U200 is also Thread over Matter certified, which means that you can include it in your Thread network if you already have a border router present. In our case, we’re using Home Assistant with the OpenThreadRouter integration to make it a border router, that can talk to the Thread enabled devices.
Although the U200 supports Homekey on your iPhone you need a Thread router from Apples ecosystem (AppleTV 4K or Homepod Mini) or a Google Nest Hub Gen 2 if you want to use your Android phone. The OpenThreadRouter integration doesn’t support Homekey, so you can’t use the NFC unlocking feature.
Since the lock is part of the Thread network it is also directly integrated into Home Assistant. From there we can read out the lock status as well as the battery level. Unfortunately Matter over Thread doesn’t yet support other features. It would be really nice to manage users on the device from within Home Assistant.
(Un-)Locking mechanisms
The keypad comes with a few options to lock/unlock your door and depending on your use case or preference you use any of the following. Like I already explained, we usually use our cellphones while our daughter uses her fingerprint.
NFC
I already explained it in the configuration section, if your setup supports it you can use Apples Homekey feature to unlock your door using your iphone. Aqara also sells NFC key fobs that you can use for this. You can assign a key fob to a person, thus you have an audit trail of who unlocked which door.
There are alternatives to the official NFC fobs from Aqara that you can buy on AliExpress and Co., but from what I read online it seems that only some are actually working with the U200.
Fingerprints
If you want to make sure that a key fob isn’t lost and used by someone else, an alternative could be fingerprints. Through the Aqara you can add fingerprints to a users profile. To do this you just need to put the finger you would like to assign on the fingerprint reader of the keypad multiple times until most of the surface area of the finger has been scanned.
Entry Codes
The classical variant of unlocking your smart door lock with a keypad is the use of entry codes. Just like you would input fingerprints and assign them to a profile, you can do the same with entry codes. Select the profile that a code should be assigned to and afterwards press the combination on the keypad.
If you do not fully trust that person, maybe it’s a temporary renter through AriBnB and such, then you can also define an expiration time for the code. Making it useless after the configured date.
Lifetime of codes
Another great feature of this device is the option to create entry codes with a fixed validity period. This means that after a date/time that you set with the code it can’t be used anymore. The Aqara U200 supports one time keys as well as keys with a fixed date.
What’s even greater is that it also supports periodic keys. This way you could grant access to this door only on specific days of the week to let the dog walker in and collect your dog or your cleaning person or someone else. We don’t need this, but it can be pretty useful I think.
One-Time Passwords
Another option that I personally don’t think I would need, is the use of One-Time codes. These, as the name implies, can be used just a single time and afterwards aren’t valid anymore. For this the Aqara app generates a 6-digit code, that is valid for up to 10 minutes.
Manual unlocking
It’s always good to have a (mechanical) failsafe. Especially when you are relying on a device that is run by firm-/software. And although the Aqara U200 was very reliable since we bought it, it is good to know that you can still use your keys from the outside to unlock your door. And from the inside a nob makes it possible to manually turn the key inside the lock. Making it always possible to open it almost like you used to. Only a smart cylinder would fully replace add the normal manual unlocking feeling that we’re used to.
Home Automation
Of course next to adding convenience to the way we can open the door to our mudroom, another selling point was the integration into our home automation. Yes, I admit that it once again was the case where I was thinking about possible automations after I actually bought the device. Well at least when you think about automations that aren’t obvious.
We have one automation that runs every day at 11pm, which is basically the go to bed routine that does things you would usually do before going to bed. And in this the smart door lock fits perfectly. It automatically locks the door if it was still unlocked. Before I always did a sweep before going to bed checking all the doors.
One game changer that the lock brought to the table was automatic opening via presence detection. Usually when you arrive with the car the first thing you would like to do is go inside. So I added an automation that would open the mudroom door when our car came home. This way you could immediately go inside, upon leaving the car.
Unfortunately our car manufacturer crossed my plans shortly after I added this automation, because live GPS tracking of the car (including Geofencing and some other things) is part of a subscription that ran out and we didn’t feel the need to resubscribe. So for now the automation is deactivated and I will have to come up with another way of determining if the car is arriving.
Idea: I will probably let the Reolink camera in the carport notify me of our car arriving and then after re-launching my Frigate instance let it detect the license plate of our car to then open the lock.
Verdict
I didn’t buy the smart look because of its esthetics that is for sure. The main device for turning the key is pretty clunky. Granted the fact that we have a plate on our lock that raises the device almost a centimeter makes it look even worse then when it’s directly fixed to the doorframe. Although it is pretty sturdy the main device looks kind of plasticky I must say.
But for the first automatic door lock that finds its way into our home it is totally acceptable. Especially when you look at the convenience it brings.
What I like
Local / Matter based integration
Having everything work locally without depending on the cloud is always the most achievable goal. And this device is totally not relying on any cloud service being up or wifi / internet connectivity at all. You can always use Bluetooth as the last resort if all other options fail.
Versatile (un-)lockig mechanisms
Speaking of options. The large variety of options to choose for locking and unlocking the device is great. This way you always have the best variant for each use case available. From using codes via the keypad for temporary access to fingerprints for people you don’t trust to hold a device yet, there is always a good option at your disposal.
What I don’t like
Clunkyness of the main device
I’ve said it already. The shape of the keypad is ok-ish. It has physical buttons and an elongated form factor. Therefore you can put it nicely on a doorframe without looking too alien.
But the main device is pretty cluncy. Sure, you will only see it from the inside of your house, but I’m not convinced that this couldn’t be engineered in a smaller form factor.
Homekey not working with Open Border Router
This actually bothers me a lot. I know not everything is available in the Matter standard and the CSA is tirelessly working on adding more stuff. But as of now this is a big issue for marketing and adoption of the standard as consumer (like me) would like to have the same features available that they have when using the ecosystem of the manufacturer.
The only thing for now probably is to wait and pray that the standard will catch up and manufacturers to be willing to have feature parity when it comes to the way you can communicate with their devices.
No configuration of users through Matter
One of the things I would really like to have is the option to manage the users on the device via Matter, to be able to quickly provision the list of users available to use the lock.
Quiet unlock not possible through Matter
This one bothers me even more. I think it is an amazing feature to be able to silently open and close the lock, because it actually is pretty loud when it turns the key in the cylinder.
So usually when I’m coming home from shopping groceries and the kids are already sound asleep, I would like to be able to open the door silently as I have no idea if the door to the mudroom is closed and you can hear the lock turning in the hallway.